Krill Oil vs Fish Oil: Which One Should You Take?

A married couple sharing morning coffee at the kitchen table, each with a Coffee and Captains mug

Krill oil and fish oil both provide omega-3s and are used as omega-3 supplements for heart and joint health; the main difference is that krill oil’s omega-3s are mostly bound to phospholipids, while fish oil’s are mostly in triglyceride form. Neither is the right choice for everyone, so consider the form, serving size, pill size, your diet and what your doctor recommends.

The last kid moved out on Saturday. Just getting started.

When the house gets quieter, there is room for new routines. Maybe the two of you are taking longer breakfasts, making plans, or simply enjoying a coffee without rushing out the door. If you’re looking at omega-3 supplements, here’s what’s useful to know before choosing one.

What is different about krill oil and fish oil?

Both are sources of omega-3s, including EPA and DHA. The difference people often ask about is the form those omega-3s come in.

In krill oil, much of the omega-3 is bound to phospholipids. In fish oil, it is mostly in triglyceride form. Those are different forms of fat. Knowing the difference can help you understand a label, but it doesn’t settle which one is right for you.

So, krill oil vs omega 3 is not quite an either-or comparison. Krill oil is one kind of omega-3 supplement. Fish oil is another. Both can be considered as supplements for heart and joint health, but their serving sizes and labels can differ. If you’ve been told to take a particular amount of EPA or DHA, compare the actual label with your clinician’s advice.

A couple around 60 enjoying coffee together at a diner, with two small softgels on the table

Krill oil, smaller pills, and how many you swallow

Pill size matters when you take something every day. Search for krill oil smaller pills and you’ll find people trying to work out whether a supplement will fit into their morning without a fuss.

Captains Krill Oil comes as tiny softgels. Two softgels a day is our whole serving. That’s the simple answer for our product. Other products may have different serving sizes, so check the label rather than assuming one capsule equals another.

We’re not here to criticize anyone’s capsules. The practical question is which serving you’ll remember and feel comfortable taking.

What about krill oil burps?

It’s a fair question. People search for krill oil burps because they want to know what taking a supplement might be like for them.

Some Captains customers mention little or no fishy taste or aftertaste in their reviews. That is what those customers report. It is not a promise that you will have the same experience, and we can’t promise any supplement will not cause a burp.

Freshness is worth checking. A softgel should not have a strong, unpleasant smell. If you want to check yours, open one and take a sniff. A mild, clean, sea-like scent is what we look for. If something seems off, stop and contact the seller or maker.

We also publish results for each Captains lot. Look up the number printed on your bottle cap at captainskrilloil.com/lots. The latest posted lot, 80144-2, reports a peroxide value below 0.19 mEq/kg, against a listed maximum of 5.0. Peroxide value is the freshness measure shown on the lot record.

Check your lot. You’re the judge.

If Captains doesn’t feel right for you, our promise is simple: Feel better or it’s free. See the guarantee details.

Two tiny softgels beside coffee mugs during a relaxed morning at home

How much krill oil a day?

For Captains, it’s two tiny softgels a day. We take them with morning coffee, because a daily habit is easier to remember when it fits into something you already do.

We call it Coffee & Captains …for Life!

Other krill oil products may have a different serving size, so follow the directions on the bottle you have. If your doctor has suggested a specific omega-3 amount, ask how that fits with the product label rather than trying to match servings by guesswork.

You might not need either

If you eat oily fish a couple of times a week, you may already be covered. We would rather say that than tell you to add a supplement you may not need.

Diet matters, and an omega-3 supplement is not a replacement for a varied diet. If you’re unsure whether your usual meals meet your needs, ask your doctor or a registered dietitian. For more on food sources, see our short guide to dietary sources of omega-3s.

A few questions people ask next

Does krill oil work faster?

There isn’t a simple timing answer we can give you. People and products differ, and we can’t promise when you might notice anything. If you’re trying a supplement, follow its label and check with your clinician about what to expect.

Can you take krill oil with coffee?

Yes. We take ours with coffee. If you prefer, take it with breakfast or another meal instead. The best time to take krill oil is a time that fits your routine.

Does krill oil need to be refrigerated?

For Captains, refrigeration is not required. Store it in a cool, dry place away from heat and light. See our answer about storing krill oil.

A married couple sharing a morning coffee on the porch, with two tiny softgels on the table

Is krill oil a blood thinner?

If you take a blood thinner, or have questions about how a supplement fits with your health or medicines, ask your doctor before taking it. We can’t advise on your personal medical situation.

Can you take krill oil and fish oil together?

Ask your doctor or pharmacist before combining supplements. They can help you consider the products and amounts you’re taking.

Which one should you take?

There isn’t one answer for every person. Krill oil and fish oil provide omega-3s in different forms, and product serving sizes vary. Look at the label, consider the routine you’ll stick with, and ask your doctor if you have questions about what’s appropriate for you.

For Captains, the routine is two tiny softgels with coffee. Every lot is tested, and the results are there for you to check. If the kids have moved out and the mornings are yours again, you have time to find a routine that fits.

Coffee & Captains …for Life!

All of us at Captains