Krill Oil vs Fish Oil: Which One Should You Take?

Krill oil and fish oil both provide omega-3s and are used as omega-3 supplements for heart and joint health; the main difference is that krill oil’s omega-3s are mostly bound to phospholipids, while fish oil’s are mostly in triglyceride form. Neither is the right choice for everyone, so consider the form, serving size, pill size, your diet and what your doctor recommends.

The last kid moved out on Saturday. Just getting started.

When the house gets quieter, there is room for new routines. Maybe the two of you are taking longer breakfasts, making plans, or simply enjoying a coffee without rushing out the door. If you’re looking at omega-3 supplements, here’s what’s useful to know before choosing one.

What is different about krill oil and fish oil?

Both are sources of omega-3s, including EPA and DHA. The difference people often ask about is the form those omega-3s come in.

In krill oil, much of the omega-3 is bound to phospholipids. In fish oil, it is mostly in triglyceride form. Those are different forms of fat. Knowing the difference can help you understand a label, but it doesn’t settle which one is right for you.

So, krill oil vs omega 3 is not quite an either-or comparison. Krill oil is one kind of omega-3 supplement. Fish oil is another. Both can be considered as supplements for heart and joint health, but their serving sizes and labels can differ. If you’ve been told to take a particular amount of EPA or DHA, compare the actual label with your clinician’s advice.

A couple around 60 enjoying coffee together at a diner, with two small softgels on the table

Krill oil, smaller pills, and how many you swallow

Pill size matters when you take something every day. Search for krill oil smaller pills and you’ll find people trying to work out whether a supplement will fit into their morning without a fuss.

Captains Krill Oil comes as tiny softgels. Two softgels a day is our whole serving. That’s the simple answer for our product. Other products may have different serving sizes, so check the label rather than assuming one capsule equals another.

We’re not here to criticize anyone’s capsules. The practical question is which serving you’ll remember and feel comfortable taking.

What about krill oil burps?

It’s a fair question. People search for krill oil burps because they want to know what taking a supplement might be like for them.

Some Captains customers mention little or no fishy taste or aftertaste in their reviews. That is what those customers report. It is not a promise that you will have the same experience, and we can’t promise any supplement will not cause a burp.

Freshness is worth checking. A softgel should not have a strong, unpleasant smell. If you want to check yours, open one and take a sniff. A mild, clean, sea-like scent is what we look for. If something seems off, stop and contact the seller or maker.

We also publish results for each Captains lot. Look up the number printed on your bottle cap at captainskrilloil.com/lots. The latest posted lot, 80144-2, reports a peroxide value below 0.19 mEq/kg, against a listed maximum of 5.0. Peroxide value is the freshness measure shown on the lot record.

Check your lot. You’re the judge.

If Captains doesn’t feel right for you, our promise is simple: Feel better or it’s free. See the guarantee details.

Two tiny softgels beside coffee mugs during a relaxed morning at home

How much krill oil a day?

For Captains, it’s two tiny softgels a day. We take them with morning coffee, because a daily habit is easier to remember when it fits into something you already do.

We call it Coffee & Captains …for Life!

Other krill oil products may have a different serving size, so follow the directions on the bottle you have. If your doctor has suggested a specific omega-3 amount, ask how that fits with the product label rather than trying to match servings by guesswork.

You might not need either

If you eat oily fish a couple of times a week, you may already be covered. We would rather say that than tell you to add a supplement you may not need.

Diet matters, and an omega-3 supplement is not a replacement for a varied diet. If you’re unsure whether your usual meals meet your needs, ask your doctor or a registered dietitian. For more on food sources, see our short guide to dietary sources of omega-3s.

A few questions people ask next

Does krill oil work faster?

There isn’t a simple timing answer we can give you. People and products differ, and we can’t promise when you might notice anything. If you’re trying a supplement, follow its label and check with your clinician about what to expect.

Can you take krill oil with coffee?

Yes. We take ours with coffee. If you prefer, take it with breakfast or another meal instead. The best time to take krill oil is a time that fits your routine.

Does krill oil need to be refrigerated?

For Captains, refrigeration is not required. Store it in a cool, dry place away from heat and light. See our answer about storing krill oil.

A married couple sharing a morning coffee on the porch, with two tiny softgels on the table

Is krill oil a blood thinner?

If you take a blood thinner, or have questions about how a supplement fits with your health or medicines, ask your doctor before taking it. We can’t advise on your personal medical situation.

Can you take krill oil and fish oil together?

Ask your doctor or pharmacist before combining supplements. They can help you consider the products and amounts you’re taking.

Which one should you take?

There isn’t one answer for every person. Krill oil and fish oil provide omega-3s in different forms, and product serving sizes vary. Look at the label, consider the routine you’ll stick with, and ask your doctor if you have questions about what’s appropriate for you.

For Captains, the routine is two tiny softgels with coffee. Every lot is tested, and the results are there for you to check. If the kids have moved out and the mornings are yours again, you have time to find a routine that fits.

Coffee & Captains …for Life!

All of us at Captains

Does Krill Oil Lower Cholesterol or Triglycerides?

Modestly, and mostly triglycerides, and only at a dose roughly double what a standard bottle gives you. The pooled trial evidence shows real movement in blood fats; the single best-designed trial at four grams a day found no change in fasting triglycerides at all. Both of those things are true.

Here is the whole picture, numbers included.

First, a word the label and your blood test both use

“Triglyceride” means two different things in this conversation.

On a blood panel, triglycerides are a fat circulating in your bloodstream — the number your doctor watches. On a fish oil bottle, “triglyceride form” describes the chemical vehicle the omega-3 rides in, which is a completely separate subject. Krill oil carries its EPA and DHA on phospholipids instead. That is a real difference in the vehicle, and we wrote about it in phospholipid vs. triglyceride omega-3s. It is not a claim about what happens to the number on your lab report.

This page is about the lab report.

What the pooled trials actually found

The most-cited analysis is Ursoniu and colleagues, published in Nutrition Reviews in 2017. They pooled 7 randomized controlled trials — 14 treatment arms, 662 people, 427 on krill oil and 235 on control. The results:

  • LDL cholesterol down about 15.5 mg/dL
  • Triglycerides down about 14.0 mg/dL
  • HDL cholesterol up about 6.7 mg/dL
  • Total cholesterol: moved, but not enough to reach statistical significance

Those are respectable numbers. (Ursoniu et al., Nutrition Reviews 75(5):361.)

Now the other sentence in the same paper: the effective dosages were at least 2 grams a day, for at least 12 weeks.

A standard krill oil serving — ours included — is one gram a day. Two softgels. If you take the label dose and expect the meta-analysis result, you are taking half the dose that produced it, and the studies that produced it ran for three months. That is not a knock on krill oil. It is arithmetic, and you deserve to have it done in front of you before you buy anything. We go into the whole dose question in how much krill oil you should take a day.

The trial that found nothing

In 2018, Norwegian researchers ran the experiment properly in the Journal of Nutritional Science: 36 adults with mildly elevated fasting triglycerides, randomized for 8 weeks to krill oil, to eating lean and fatty fish per dietary guidelines, or to a control oil. The krill group took eight capsules a day — 4 grams of oil, four times a typical serving.

Fasting triglycerides did not change between the groups. Not in the krill arm, not in the fish arm. The krill oil did shift the lipid content of the smallest VLDL particles and did slightly better than fish on blood glucose, but the headline number — the one people buy krill oil for — sat still. (Journal of Nutritional Science, 2018.)

We sell krill oil and we are telling you about the null trial, because you will find it eventually and we would rather you heard it here.

The part that should genuinely give you pause

Omega-3s pull triglycerides down. They can also push LDL up.

The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements states it plainly: higher intakes of EPA and DHA reduced triglycerides and raised HDL, and also raised LDL (NIH ODS omega-3 fact sheet). In the lipidology literature the rise runs roughly 5–10% at 4 grams a day of a mixed EPA/DHA product, and the effect tracks with how hard the triglycerides fall — the harder the drop, the more the LDL tends to drift. Purified-EPA prescription products don’t show it; mixed EPA and DHA products do.

Krill oil is a mixed EPA and DHA oil. Nobody has run that specific question at scale in krill, which means the honest answer is: we don’t know how much of that applies to krill. If you are taking omega-3 for your lipids, get the panel redrawn in three months and look at all four numbers, not the one you were hoping to move.

What krill oil did not move

A 2023 systematic review in Diabetes & Metabolic Syndrome updated the picture and found the lipid benefits again — total cholesterol, LDL, triglycerides. It also found no effect on systolic or diastolic blood pressure, fasting glucose, insulin, HbA1c, HOMA-IR, body weight, BMI, waist circumference, or C-reactive protein (2023 updated meta-analysis).

And one wrinkle worth naming, because it argues against us: the lipid effects clustered in trials that were shorter than 8 weeks and in leaner participants. The 2017 analysis said the effect needed 12 weeks. Those two findings don’t sit comfortably together, and when subgroup patterns disagree like that it usually means the underlying effect is smaller and shakier than the headline suggests.

You might not need us

If your triglycerides are genuinely high, the 200 to 499 mg/dL range or above, a krill oil capsule is not the tool. The American Heart Association’s 2019 science advisory reviewed 17 trials and concluded that 4 grams a day of prescription omega-3 lowers triglycerides by 20 to 30% (Skulas-Ray et al., Circulation 2019;140:e673). That is a doctor’s conversation and a prescription, not a supplement purchase.

Two more honest exits:

  • You eat fatty fish twice a week. The Norwegian trial’s fish arm did about what the krill arm did.
  • You are on a statin and your numbers are fine. A statin is doing the LDL job already. Adding an omega-3 for cholesterol reasons is chasing a small effect on top of a large one — see our answer on taking krill oil with Lipitor. Talk to whoever prescribed it.

Where Captains fits

We do not claim our oil will move your cholesterol. What we can tell you is what is in the bottle.

Captains Krill Oil™ is small batch, from a small family business, made the same way for more than a decade. It is a natural product, so it varies a little lot to lot. Every lot is tested and we publish the results. The lot number is on top of the cap. Check your lot.

None of that changes the trial evidence above. It just means that when you decide what the evidence is worth, you know exactly what you would be taking.

Quick answers

Does krill oil lower LDL cholesterol?

Pooled trials found LDL about 15.5 mg/dL lower on krill oil, but the effective doses were 2 grams a day or more for at least 12 weeks. At the same time, the NIH notes that omega-3 intake overall can raise LDL. Have your panel redrawn rather than assuming a direction.

How long does krill oil take to affect cholesterol?

The 2017 meta-analysis found the clearest effects in trials running 12 weeks or longer. Three months is the honest window before a repeat blood test tells you anything. Anything you read at four weeks is noise.

Is krill oil better than fish oil for triglycerides?

There is no strong evidence that it is. The 2018 Norwegian trial compared krill oil against eating lean and fatty fish at matched omega-3 intake and neither moved fasting triglycerides. Krill’s phospholipid vehicle absorbs well, but absorption is not the same thing as a lipid result.

Can I take krill oil with a statin?

Many people do, and there is no well-established interaction, but this is a question for your prescriber and not for a supplement label. If your LDL is already controlled on a statin, adding krill oil for cholesterol reasons is chasing a small effect on top of a large one.

What dose of krill oil did the cholesterol studies use?

At least 2 grams a day in the trials where effects showed up — roughly double a standard one-gram serving. The 2018 null trial used 4 grams a day and still saw no triglyceride change, which is why we would rather you knew the dose figures than the headline.

This article is information, not medical advice. Blood lipids are a conversation to have with your doctor, with a blood test in hand.

Honest answer, not a pitch. — captainskrilloil.com

Try it the way it’s caught. Get it delivered monthly. Stocking up? 3-pack, free shipping. Check any lot’s test results at captainskrilloil.com/lots.

Q: I take Lipitor. Do I still need a krill oil supplement?

A: Well, none of us at Captains went to med school. Or pharmacy school. You really need to ask that to someone who did. Preferably someone who graduated, and passed whatever licensing exam you have to pass. And is currently employed as either a Doctor or Pharmacist. That would be our advice.

Don’t take our word for it.

We’re the krill oil from a boat, not a factory — but you should hear it from customers, not from us. Real, unedited reviews from Google and Amazon, each linked to its original.

Read 50+ real Captains Krill Oil reviews →

Try it the way it’s caught. Get it delivered monthly. Stocking up? 3-pack, free shipping. Check any lot’s test results at captainskrilloil.com/lots.

Q: Can I take krill oil along with my other blood pressure medication?

A: Sorry, we’re sea captains, not doctors. You’ll have to ask that question to yours.

Don’t take our word for it.

We’re the krill oil from a boat, not a factory — but you should hear it from customers, not from us. Real, unedited reviews from Google and Amazon, each linked to its original.

Read 50+ real Captains Krill Oil reviews →

Try it the way it’s caught. Get it delivered monthly. Stocking up? 3-pack, free shipping. Check any lot’s test results at captainskrilloil.com/lots.

Q: Can krill oil raise my HDL or “good” cholesterol?

A: It certainly can! A study that was published in the Alternative Medicine Review, found that krill oil worked to increase HDL “good” cholesterol levels by 4.2%.

Don’t take our word for it.

We’re the krill oil from a boat, not a factory — but you should hear it from customers, not from us. Real, unedited reviews from Google and Amazon, each linked to its original.

Read 50+ real Captains Krill Oil reviews →

Try it the way it’s caught. Get it delivered monthly. Stocking up? 3-pack, free shipping. Check any lot’s test results at captainskrilloil.com/lots.

Q: Will krill oil lower my blood pressure?

A: Krill oil has been clinically shown to support heart health. A study in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology, found that a minimum dose of 500mg of EPA and DHA, the two omega-3′s found in krill oil, are effective markers in managing blood pressure.

Don’t take our word for it.

We’re the krill oil from a boat, not a factory — but you should hear it from customers, not from us. Real, unedited reviews from Google and Amazon, each linked to its original.

Read 50+ real Captains Krill Oil reviews →

Try it the way it’s caught. Get it delivered monthly. Stocking up? 3-pack, free shipping. Check any lot’s test results at captainskrilloil.com/lots.